I believe this is a discussion which already kind of occurred in the past, and nothing will probably come out of it. Nor will any “side” change its position one bit. But just to say it, I HIGHLY disagree. This is the kind of reasoning behind every tyran, genocide and everything you want. Ok, right, we’re only talking about the deletion of a few ascii characters here, but still, I really hate this belief of the supposed “need to” make “tough decisions” which “great” people would make, which sure are bad for some, but overall would be for the “greater good”. Trust them, they know. Better than the affected people and better than you. Probably even better than everybody. (Maybe it’s even the case here, I’m not really saying otherwise)
No offence (I feel I needed to place it somewhere
I hope it will help a little). Sure, your forum, you set the rules and how it works. In the end, the people can leave and there is a view it’s their own fault if they came in the first place.
Pardon me, I am a “preservationist”, maybe a too hardcore one
What I would urge every forum owner/admin to do is, however you’re dealing with your forum, its content and its users, to try to make this VERY CLEAR from the beginning. Say what you do and do what you say. Then I guess everything is fine. Everybody knows, is warned, and can act accordingly. (for topics deleting automatically after 30 days, it seems clearly announced. Post in it at your own peril. Sure, I admit this)