Hi there. We have a Topic called “Introduce Yourself” where new users share a bit about themselves and what they hope to gain from our forum. Users are meant to introduce themselves using the blue “Reply” button, as in reply-to-the-topic. However, they sometimes just click the first reply button that they see, which is the grey reply-to-the-last-post on the page button. Introducing yourself should be a reply to the Topic. Responses to an individual’s introduction should be a Reply to Post. What are some ways I can adjust our settings to make this clearer? I don’t want new users to introduce themselves in reply to someone else’s introduction because each user’s introduction can have a discussion going on–to be suddenly interrupted with “Hi, I’m John Doe, I’m new here and I’ve got 3 questions to ask.” Thanks – EDIT: Related to this issue is the fact that replies to replies are not indented to indicate when a post is a reply to the topic or a reply to a reply. If there’s a setting that will help make this clearer too I’d love to know about it. Thanks!

[image] CapedCrusader: What are some ways I can adjust our settings to make this clearer? You could rename the grey “Reply” button as “Reply to user” and the blue one as “Reply to thread”. Unfortunately, this is not directly possible in the admin backend, so you’d need a CSS hack with text:after (hope that works, didn’t test). The admin backend includes an extensive set of settings to adapt the site’s text under “Admin → Customize → Text content”, but unfortunately both reply buttons are governed by the same text key js.topic.reply.title. But I can well imagine the Discourse developers would introduce two separate text keys for the grey and blue reply buttons, if you ask. It’s a reasonable feature and I have wished for it in the past myself. In the meantime, whenever somebody uses the wrong reply button you can correct their action as an admin user as discussed in this thread: [image] Reparent a post Support Is it possible to reparent a post in a topic? Especially, when someone posts a comment as an answer (when using the Question Answer Plugin), and someone posts a comment to an answer as an answer… [image] CapedCrusader: Related to this issue is the fact that replies to replies are not indented to indicate when a post is a reply to the topic or a reply to a reply. This – the semi-flat thread model – is one of the core features and innovations in Discourse. There are no settings to configure this and I propose you better get “used to it”. Once forum users get all used to this thread model, it’s really the better one: instead of a confusing 7-10 levels of indentation, the thread is one linear flow, just as a verbal discussion. Once people start making heavy use of the “quote” feature to reply to multiple posts at once, they “got it”.

In addition to this, it is a bit hacky, but you CAN target a specific topic in your CSS if need be.

Just wondering if perhaps Discourse has split the js.topic.reply.title so we can easily rename the two Reply buttons to Reply to User and Reply to Topic? If so, can we get detailed instructions on how to make this change (for a non css knowledgable admin)? Thanks

I agree. I’ve argued for it in another topic: [image] Request for splitting js.topic.reply.title Feature @Silvanus who proposed this is a native Finnish speaker like me. In Finnish language we have a perfect word to translate “Reply” (“Vastaa”). For me the words are perfect synonyms so if an English speaker understands, a Finnish speaker should understand, too. It doesn’t mean that you are wrong, though: there could be other languages where it could be a real issue. I still think I know why @Silvanus wanted to see this happen and I agree with him. I think it’s more about forum cultures. Here in M…

Is it difficult to do, or is there another reason?

Reply to Topic vs. Reply to Last Post

Product Support

codinghorror (Jeff Atwood) July 18, 2019, 9:33pm 6

Unlikely to happen, for the record. That’s why the topic is closed.

Topic		Replies	Views
My users think a reply will be a private reply UX	19	2443	March 20, 2021
Topic footer Reply button can break the thread UX	10	1007	April 5, 2023
Topic setting: make reply-to-post button act as "reply as new topic" Feature	8	2502	December 9, 2017
Is there a way to link replies after they are posted? Product Support moderation	20	834	August 21, 2024
Question/suggestion about arrow/icon referencing replied to post Feature	14	1938	May 17, 2019

Reply to Topic vs. Reply to Last Post

Related topics