If you compare the provided screenshots you’ll see that Discourse.org had more badges under the “Getting Started” category than my instance. The badges that are missing are somehow put into the “Other” category on my instance and they should be in “Getting Started”. That’s the problem.
For instance the “First Quote” badge is categorized as “Getting Started” on Discourse.org and appears as such. The Discourse rebuild normally puts the “First Quote” badge under “Getting Started” but in my instance it appears under “Other”