Staged users getting welcome message

I have repro on the personal forum I am setting up now and on community.namati.org. The offending setting appears to be the one highlighted in the screenshot below.

Staged users will get the welcome message from discobot if welcome post is not disabled, and “send all new users a welcome message with a quick start guide” is selected.

Staged users will not get the welcome message if “Start the new user tutorial for all new users” is selected.