Hi there, Over time our forum has become rather cluttered with old topics so we are undergoing a clean up task. I have a couple of quick questions (apologies if these have been answered elsewhere!)… What is the difference between Archived and Closed topics? I have seen elsewhere that an archived topic cannot be altered at all whereas a closed topic simply cannot be replied to. We were hoping that closed topics would still be visible within their category whereas archived topics would only be available to view if they are searched for. Is this possible? It seems at the moment that archived topics can still be viewed within their category? Is there a way to bulk-update a number of topics, perhaps where there hasn’t been an update in X amount of time? This clean-up is long overdue so manually archiving each individual topic will not be an insignificant task! Thanks in advance. Josh

[תמונה] JoshDevInit: We were hoping that closed topics would still be visible within their category whereas archived topics would only be available to view if they are searched for. Is this possible? No, that’s not possible. [תמונה] JoshDevInit: Is there a way to bulk-update a number of topics, perhaps where there hasn’t been an update in X amount of time? In any topics list, you can click the “list” icon left to the “Topics” header to enable the bulk selection of topics. After selecting some topics, click the :wrench: on the right and select either “Close” or “Archive” topics.

Thanks for the swift reply! So am I right in saying that a post will not be bumped when it is archived, but will remain in the Category itself forever (or until it’s deleted)? And with regard to bulk updating topics, if we use the ‘auto close topic hours’ on a category, will that be actioned against all existing topics that haven’t been updated within that window or will that only work for subsequent posts/topics? Thanks, Josh

[תמונה] JoshDevInit: What is the difference between Archived and Closed topics? More info: Best practices for archiving topics - #4 by codinghorror

We have a guide that explain the difference between archived, closed and unlisted topics. [תמונה] Understanding closed, unlisted, and archived topics Site Management bookmark This guide explains the differences between closed, unlisted, and archived topics in Discourse, including their characteristics, visual indicators, and use cases. person_raising_hand Required user level: All users Discourse offers several ways to manage topics beyond just leaving them open. You can close topics, archive them, or unlist them, depending on your goal. Each of these states serves a different purpose and has specific effects on how topics are displayed, interacted wi…

Archiving vs Closing & Bulk Topic Update

תמיכה

dax (Daniela) 29 בינואר,‏ 2019,‏ 3:17pm 5

We have a guide that explain the difference between archived, closed and unlisted topics.

נושא		תגובות	צפיות
Best practices for archiving topics Feature	30	15644	7 באוקטובר,‏ 2016
Understanding closed, unlisted, and archived topics Site Management explanation	3	32839	13 ביולי,‏ 2025
TL4s posting in archived topics Product Support	5	1493	7 באוקטובר,‏ 2019
Filter closed but not archived Product Support	2	481	29 באוגוסט,‏ 2021
Move post to existing topic - how to hide closed topics from search? Product Support	2	352	16 באפריל,‏ 2024

Archiving vs Closing & Bulk Topic Update

נושאים קשורים