Hey all, On our self-hosted Discourse instance with the chat-integration plugin, we have it set up so that new threads in a certain category trigger notifications in our company Slack in a certain channel via “First post only” filter. It sometimes occurs that people post in the wrong place and then edit it into the category after the fact, or sometimes we manually merge some responses into a new thread in that category. Sometimes this is done by staff members, but more often than not by our community members and then we’d still like to see a notification of the thread. Under these circumstances however, we do not see any notifications in Slack. It seems to be that the notifications only get triggered when people actually post it straight in that category, and not from later edits or merge actions. Is this something that could be implemented (perhaps as option), or is this intentionally designed this way? Thanks, Thomas

Did you ever find a workaround for this?

Unfortunately not – we’ve instead told our community moderators to close posts that are in the wrong category and linking the user to the one that they should post in instead, rather than editing it into the category. Our moderators usually catch wrongly categorized posts very quickly after they are posted, so this “works” for us for now, albeit not very convenient.

[image] Hooksmith: close posts that are in the wrong category and linking the user to the one that they should post in instead, rather than editing it into the category. That’s really unfortunate. There is a recent change, however: [image] Publication of Timed Topics don't trigger new topic notifications Bug First of all, thank you for report the issue. I think I fixed that issue in this commit: FIX: correct notification when tag or category is added (#8801) · discourse/discourse@20e7fb1 · GitHub Basically, I improved a little bit the logic around notification If the user has already seen the post, the type of notification should be edited. The case for that is when for example OP will add category or tag which is watched by another user. However, when the user hasn’t yet seen the post, the type… You may want to test it out again…

"First post only" filter to take into account edits/merge into category after the fact?

Product Support

downey (Michael Downey) January 31, 2020, 6:43pm 4

That’s really unfortunate. There is a recent change, however:

You may want to test it out again…

Topic		Replies	Views
Published/Scheduled Posts 'Watching First Post' notifications not being triggered Product Support notifications	8	839	August 4, 2023
Notifications when a topic is recategorized Bug	14	2443	May 8, 2018
One admin gets notifications for topics and private messages Product Support	21	3465	July 22, 2016
Any way to prevent notifications for post merges, moves? Product Support	24	4059	November 16, 2021
Slack category to show only replies in a specific Discourse category Product Support chat-integration	3	2818	November 29, 2018

"First post only" filter to take into account edits/merge into category after the fact?

Related topics