Right, I think we’re finding that these are often human spammers who will always learn workarounds, and requiring a post to get permission might also result in normal users posting meaningless things to meet the requirements.
We’ve also seem situations where a spammer will make something that looks like a normal post (which they might have even copy & pasted from somewhere else in the forum!), and then come back and edit it later to add spam. These spammers can be very persistent.