Why this user keeps showing in review tab without accepted button?

Ah I think I understand the problem now. The user was created, but the associated reviewable record was not marked as approved.

To fix this you will need the id of the reviewable item. You can get this by clicking on the date on the reviewable item, and the url will look like /review/1234 - 1234 is the number you want.

Then you can open a rails console:

rails c

And type this:

Reviewable.find(1234).update_column(:status, 1)

If you find accessing the database easier, the query would be this:

UPDATE reviewables SET status = 1 WHERE id = 1234