Wow, that means that keeping the agreed number constant, as the disagreed number increases, the score will be better and better (when disagreed > agreed).
A more reasonable and direct formula may be something like:
(agreed * agreed) - (disagreed * disagreed)
That is, the agreed will always make the score higher, and the disagreed will always make it lower. I don’t know if there is a need to make the formula more complex than that, but anyway, just my opinion (if it’s ok for the score to be negative).
I think this is okay, though. Is there a problem with it, considering that both values (one that should increase and the other that should decrease the score) are the same?