I have a look at other products every year. Tribe is very attractive visually but under the hood it isn’t as strong as it says.
For example, moderation tools are limited in their free option so I would have to upgrade to a paid Tribe product (min. $399 per month) when I could keep my cheap Discourse site for as little as $5 a month or hosted for well under $100 a month
I’ve found that Tribe is more focused on selling themselves and selling products. That will suit sites that want that which is why the two aren’t really directly competing. But even if they were then Tribe skews their comparison with Discourse.
Ignores common features of Discourse:
- Basic features such as groups
- Plug-ins
- Free to use
- Fully featured e.g. moderation is not limited for free users
- Open-source
Redefines common terms to suit their purposes. Using tooltips to hide the key criterion:
- “community platform” says it is defined by the “social components on the community site”
- “Embeddable widgets” says “in valuable social elements of the community inside the product or website”
Discourse could do with a swish plug-in “store” but have a deeper look at the attractive app store. Several Tribe apps are:
- “coming soon”, still
- really basic …
- … and/or standard features in Discourse, e.g. Welcome Email
Incidentally, the Tribes comparison with Vanilla also suffers from many of the same biases.