Our forum has an “Adult only” category; posts there are unlisted. Despite that, the category is popular, and acquires a large number of likes and responses. Currently, the “Adult only” category doesn’t generate badges, and users would like them. I see that it would be possible in principle to edit badge query SQL to make this happen. But that seems drastic. Is there another/better way of handling this?

Is there a better way for us to handle “Adult only” categories and badges?

Badges are only awarded on public categories / topics and this is deeply embedded into the design.

I think what I’m asking is something like this: We’re using the “secure non public category” feature for our AO category, but there’s nothing truly secure, secret, or private about it. We just want people to opt-in to see mature content. We have a policy where everybody who says that they’re an adult and that they want access to the AO category gets access. Is there another, better way to implement our AO category? Ideally these posts would indeed be public but filtered out, or something…?

[image] dfabulich: better way for us to handle “Adult only” categories and badges? Perhaps you could make a group where people can request to join or something similar. As for categories you can create a new one where only an adult group can post. To have badges would Allow badges to be awarded in this category in the category settings of I understand correctly?

I guess you can reset the category settings to the default everyone -> see/reply/create and add it to the default muted categories? That way users need to opt-in by removing the mute?

Badges for Adult Only category

Product Support

codinghorror (Jeff Atwood) December 26, 2019, 5:38pm 2

You don’t mean unlisted, you mean a secure non public category, correct?

This is currently very much by design.

Topic		Replies	Views
Badges not granted in non public categories, despite "Allow granting of badges in this category" turned on Feature badges	3	1288	August 17, 2020
Badges & Private Communities Feature badges	26	2083	February 13, 2026
Making a category that can only be accessed with a badge? Feature	4	949	November 14, 2015
Allow badges in category security settings Feature	6	1197	July 23, 2014
Badges not being granted for restricted categories Product Support badges	31	4340	February 17, 2021

Badges for Adult Only category

Related topics