Hello, We are trying to export a single topic from one Discourse instance to either local storage or preferably another instance. The admins on the original instance support the move, but do not necessarily want to spend a lot of time working on making the move, and so we are looking for whatever solutions are available that are relatively quick and painless. Thus far, we are considering two options: [image] Move topics from one Discourse instance to another Self-Hosting Need to move some stuff from one instance of Discourse to another? There is a command line tool to export a topic, a set of topics, or an entire category, and another to import them in at the other end. Topic Export/Import one or more topics and their replies the users who posted in the topic Category Export/Import the category and all its subcategories its security settings custom groups mentioned in the security settings warning if any of the groups have ‘membership requests’ enable… [image] GitHub - pfaffman/discourse-downloader: Download a Discourse topic for offline analysis Download a Discourse topic for offline analysis While the first link is certainly the most direct way to achieve our end goal, we are not sure our admins will be on board with having to do what seems like a sizable chunk of work on their end to support the move, and so are also considering @pfaffman’s Discourse Downloader. However, if one of these options is clearly better given our needs and constraints, we’d really appreciate some insight from others who have done one or the other, or are more familiar with the process than we are. Plus, if there’s any other option we haven’t found that would be better, we would really love to mnow! Thanks for your time!

[image] orangeandblack5: what seems like a sizable chunk of work on their end to support the move The topic/category import/export command line tool boils down to a few commands and five minutes of work, at most. Did you consider the legal implications of copying users to another instance?

All users are consenting to the move, so I would not expect it to be an issue. If you think otherwise, please let me know!

[image] orangeandblack5: We are trying to export a single topic from one Discourse instance to either local storage or preferably another instance. Do you really mean one topic? Why not copy and paste in the web interface? Edit: oh yeah. A topic has many posts. Sorry. :frowning_face: Anyway, now that I understand, I think that I’d use the rake task if you can get your admins to do it. I don’t think it’s that hard.

[image] pfaffman: Why not copy and paste in the web interface? Possible reasons: You want the users, uploads, quotes, likes as well The topic has a zillion posts

Alright so The admins said no to both solutions because it would be too much work to do Their words, not mine, I’m also not a fan I don’t suppose you know how to get a .json file for not one post but the whole topic without admin perms? Edit: This might be best as its own topic, as I suppose it’s no longer in line with the title. Still, seems spammy, so I won’t.

[image] orangeandblack5: The admins said no to both solutions I don’t think you need to run @pfaffman s solution on the server. You don’t need the admins for it AFAIK.

Is this a public forum topic? In that case this should work without API key.

Wow! It does look like I wrote it such that it won’t require an API key if it’s a public topic. [image] orangeandblack5: It requires an API key. Or maybe not? I pushed a fix, so you can do a git pull and it should work now with an empty apikeys file. (I think you need to create an empty one, though). It will download a topic to a text file. I wrote it for off-line analysis of discussions, however, so I’m not sure how useful it’ll be without some work. I think that it should let you download the stuff locally, but won’t be much help (as it is) to move it to another Discourse. If you want it moved to another Discourse and it’s a public topic, you’ll need to, say, get this tool to something different. If you have a budget you can contact me or post in #marketplace.

To be honest if I was going to spend that much time I’d probably just write something that crawls the topic and manually grabs all of the individual .json files lol Unfortunately I’m not really able to give the resources to either of those options, so running the downloader may just be the best option I have. Thanks!

Easiest way to export a single topic?

Product Support

RGJ (Richard - Communiteq) January 14, 2020, 8:26am 7

I don’t think you need to run @pfaffman s solution on the server. You don’t need the admins for it AFAIK.

Topic		Replies	Views
Migrate topics from one discourse instance to another? Product Support	5	2085	November 28, 2016
Move topics from one Discourse instance to another Self-Hosting how-to	7	24139	August 20, 2026
How to download Comments and Topics Product Support	6	1385	August 10, 2022
Forum Aquisition Product Support	4	275	March 14, 2026
CLI command to migrate a single category Feature rfc , spec	4	5302	February 2, 2016

Easiest way to export a single topic?

Related topics