We’ve been discussing auto-closing older topics in our community, but for now the consensus is that it’s better to leave them open than to force people to create new topics on the same subject. Having said that, it might be nice to show a warning when someone tries to reply to an old topic to make them pause and think for a minute before they post. Is there any way to do this, or to add it through a theme component? [image]

You could probably adapt this component: [image] Warn admins/tl4 when replying to closed topics Theme component Admin Warnings Theme Component https://github.com/davidtaylorhq/discourse-admin-warnings When admins click ‘reply’ on a closed topic, they will be warned. This helps to prevent admins accidentally continuing a closed/archived discussion (much to the frustration of other forum users!). [44] Warning text is configurable as a theme setting. To install, follow the instructions here: Rather than checking the “closed” attribute, check the “bumped at” attribute instead But also, remember that we already show a warning in the composer when you reply to an old topic (desktop only)

I’ll give that a try, thanks! [image] david: But also, remember that we already show a warning in the composer when you reply to an old topic (desktop only) I’m sorry to say, but in my experience our users ignore those notices in the message composer. An ‘in your face’ warning would be better for us.

This feature already exists! You are asking for something that already happens. Try replying to a many years old topic here on meta for example. If your argument is that you need a more invasive notice, you have seriously underestimated what users can ignore — they will ignore every single thing on the screen, no matter how “invasive” you make it.

[image] codinghorror: If your argument is that you need a more invasive notice, you have seriously underestimated what users can ignore — they will ignore every single thing on the screen , no matter how “invasive” you make it. I’m afraid that is true, yes :slight_smile: Gotta try though!

Show extra invasive warning when replying to an old topic?

Product Support

bartv (Bart ) February 4, 2020, 3:46pm 5

I’m afraid that is true, yes Gotta try though!

Topic		Replies	Views
Creating a component to show last-chance warning when replying to old topics Development	6	438	October 6, 2025
Warn users that try to reply to an old post UX	6	1209	August 27, 2019
Warn admins/tl4 when replying to closed topics Theme component	14	3335	July 22, 2026
Why does reply button show for closed topics? Product Support	3	236	December 25, 2024
Make reply button unavailable immediately after closing topic Feature	23	2236	January 19, 2021

Show extra invasive warning when replying to an old topic?

Related topics