Create a private Topic only accessible to specified users

Since you are still looking for an ultimate solution, perhaps this workflow would work within the current Discourse version. It does not involve any SubCategory or Group creations:

  1. Coach begins a clinic with a listing of paid-up cohort usernames, who each have a public Accountability topic that would show the Coach their current area of interest in improving their game, or even just a public topic there that tells the Coach their history with the game etc…
  2. The coach initiates a PM to this list of cohorts and adds them each to the recipient list of a PM in which the PM topic is something like ‘Clinic March 5-12, 2020’. The 1st post text would describe the particulars and blah-blah about the clinic and asks the list respondents to reply to the PM with a one line introduction of themselves along with a note from the Coach that asks each cohort to temporarily edit their personal settings so the their ‘Website Address’ points to a direct browser address to the first post of their ‘Accountability’ topic. This is the ‘Accountability’ topic where they can each provide more information that the Coach may like to read (he might even read some of the replies from the public on that topic if it interests him :wink: ). @jord8on, this is the way that we are creating a ‘tag’ to something like your “Master the lob shot" topic you mentioned earlier :wink:
  3. When the cohorts respond with the 1 liner to the Coaches PM, the coach can then click on the cohorts avatar and then immediately click on the link to the cohorts ‘Accountability’ topic that will popup so that the Coaches can learn more about you.
  4. All communication from that point on between the coach and all the cohorts with be done as replies to this ‘Clinic March 5-12, 2020’ PM.
  5. When the clinic is over the cohorts put their WebSite Address in their account settings back to what it was before the clinic.

I think that covers your issues as I understand them and which were not fully listed in your Topic Title.