Hey there, is there any way to not automatically create a topic for every blog post we publish on our website yet still keep the discussion section? I feel it makes more sense to generate a topic automatically as long as there’s a comment on a certain blog post. Currently the logic is that the topic should exist before people can comment. Thanks in advance!

That’s unusual. I confirmed locally it was working great after my latest round of fixes. Is there anything in your /logs output you could share here? I’m curious what the error is.

[image] Jamie_Liu1: So how can I keep myself informed when it’s available? Ideally, this topic will get updated when the feature becomes available. In that case, you will get a notification about it if you set your notification level for this topic to Watching.

Okay I’ve got a PR ready for this feature: https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/9391

Wow that’s really impressive! So fast.

I just saw this feature live! Shout out to @codinghorror and @eviltrout. Thanks for being so responsive to users’ request.

Yes apologies I meant to update this topic to announce it’s now live. Can you try it out and provide feedback? We’d like to make this the default in the future but we want to make sure it’s been tested properly.

No worries. [image] eviltrout: we want to make sure it’s been tested properly. Totally. I have enabled this option and the new blog post has been unlisted automatically. [image] But the old ones are still there and I need to manually delete them. [image] Is that the right logic according to your design?

Yes, I should have been more clear that this only applies to new imports going forward.

@eviltrout Thanks for clarification. Everything is working properly so far. :grinning:

[image] eviltrout: Can you try it out and provide feedback? @eviltrout I went through the process below and found a bug: Deleted all old posts without any comment - Success Visited one of the deleted posts on our website - Success Clicked the Start Discussion button - Success Comment on the post - Failure becuase the topic is unlisted by default [image]

Not generate topic automatically for all blog posts

Product Support

Jamie_Liu1 (Jamie Liu) April 18, 2020, 1:01am 28

@eviltrout I just tried and this was happening on newly created ones too.

Topic		Replies	Views
Embedding, but don't automatically create a topic until a user chooses to comment Feature pr-welcome	55	9318	January 21, 2018
WP-discourse: comments are not pulled over WordPress	21	6535	April 20, 2017
[PAID] Avoid topic creation when blog posts are loaded Marketplace embedding	6	712	February 15, 2024
An idea for more economical comments? WordPress	16	1434	December 11, 2023
Create topic when a link is clicked Product Support	3	2515	September 30, 2019

Not generate topic automatically for all blog posts

Related topics