Is it possible to tie approvals requirement to membership in a group?

tgxworld · April 15, 2026, 8:26am

Just dropping a note here that we this feature landed in

FEATURE: Support group based category posting review modes (#38707)

committed 02:41AM - 07 Apr 26 UTC

Category approval was previously a simple boolean toggle per post type (`require…_topic_approval` / `require_reply_approval`). This made it impossible to exempt specific groups from review or to require review only for certain groups. This replaces the boolean model with a four-mode enum on `CategorySetting`: `no_one`, `everyone`, `everyone_except`, and `no_one_except`. The group-based modes pair with `CategoryPostingReviewGroup` join records to determine which groups are included or excluded. The old boolean accessors are preserved as aliases of the enum predicates for backward compatibility. With the mode now living on `CategorySetting`, the per-row `permission` column on `CategoryPostingReviewGroup` is redundant since the join table only needs to track which groups are associated with a category, not what kind of permission they have. The column is made nullable and marked readonly in a pre-deploy migration, then dropped in a post-deploy migration. On the frontend, the approval checkboxes are replaced with `ComboBox` dropdowns for the four modes and a conditional `GroupChooser` for the group-based modes, in both the legacy and simplified category editors. The simplified editor uses FormKit field-level validation to show inline errors when a group-based mode is selected without any groups. The legacy editor relies on server-side validation surfaced through `popupAjaxError`.

Closing this topic off for now

Topic		Replies	Views
Moderator approval for just one user? Support	3	79	March 31, 2025
Query on how to create a category which can be seen, but posts can't Support	7	1164	June 15, 2020
Category Group Review/Moderation Announcements category-moderators , new-feature	2	18899	November 18, 2022
Approve Topics in specific category? Support	16	2795	July 16, 2018
How to associate a category with a group Support	5	1254	December 20, 2020

Is it possible to tie approvals requirement to membership in a group?

Related topics