Proper way to secure/backup Discourse on self-hosted server?

There will never be a 100% secure way to store data, having that clear, Discourse has a really great backup process that runs in a schedulable basis.

If I don’t trust a lot of devices and I can increase monthly expenditure I’d start be offloading the backups to S3 enabling S3 replication, from there I’d have a script that copies that to my local machine and maybe once per month get everything offloaded to an external drive.

With that you have enough failure points that won’t fail all together. S3 reliability is pretty high, then you local machine should be in a pretty good state too as you use it daily and hasn’t failed (but might and surely quicker than a wide spread failure in S3).

As this secure approach doesn’t go by information security (encryption, etc). The best way is having multiple copies in multiple places.