User Trust level 1 notification but still stuck at 0

Actually this same issue is happening for me on a forum we’ve just setup. We’re still in bootstrap mode, but users are still getting stuck at trust level 0.

I am an admin there, so for the new users today I upgraded them manually. To try to recreate this issue I created a new user and walked through setting up the account. Even after checking all the boxes for TL1 (despite Bootstrap mode), I still was not promoted. I did get the confirmation email like @ondrej posted above.

In the group settings of them I had just left the trust level that is granted to None in hopes that it would just default to the standard trust levels setup by the system settings.

I’m wondering, do the Group settings have any kind of issues that supercede the Trust levels?