Yes, that’s exactly what I’m thinking about. What if someone posts a selfie? Or their phone number? They delete their account on my site, as part of that (automated) process, their Discourse account is anonymized… and then the next day, I receive a GDPR removal request. I have to remove all their personal info from my site. Now I’m stuck.
I like this idea but I doubt it would hold up under the scenario I describe above.
Another option is that, instead of anonymizing, I could just delete them entirely from Discourse. Of course, the problem is that all their old messages go away, leaving holes in topics. Hmm. Not crazy about that either.