If your WordPress login page is not at wp.site.com/wp-login.php, try setting the “Path to your Login Page” setting. It’s found on the WP Discourse SSO Provider tab. It should be set to the login page’s path. For example, if users login at wp.site.com/login, set it to /login
That might fix the problem, if not, send me a link to your Discourse site and I’ll have a look.
That setting should not need to be enabled.