My first (genuine, not antagonistic) question for you is why do you care? Community builders often put a lot of weight on growth stats but what direct benefit are they to you? It is generally better to have an extremely engaged community talking about the thing they love than a larger one with less focus.
Unless the community concepts are identical, the platform is of very little relevance, in the same way that a new platform won’t save a dying community.
TLDR; Most successful communities of interest have a community concept with a laser sharp focus.