How does Discourse replace WP comments exactly?

We’re at version 2.1.1 with WP 5.5. We don’t have comment caching turned on, and we are not using WP comments (but now no longer seeing the default form load, so that is good).

However, sometimes the custom templates load and sometimes they do not. We reverted to show comments for all posts regardless of whether the Discourse topic is private or not, but that didn’t help. I can’t figure out the why, but it seems persistent for the individual posts. Examples for public posts in public topics:

no commments, not loading discourse_no_replies_html:

no comments, is loading discourse_no_replies_html:

has comments, not loading discourse_replies_html

has comments, is loading discourse_replies_html