Just tested this on my site.
When formatted the link in the preview pane is both
a) clickable in the preview window; and
b) does open in a new tab.
If the link is not formatted the link is not clickable in the preview window as you state. ![]()
Once the reply is saved, it is clickable and does open in a new tab.
Normally I’ll just use the hyperlink icon in the reply to add a link and text and so far as I remember, they’ve always been clickable and open in a new tab from the preview pane. I usually format the text/hyperlink after creating it.
I have my personal preference set to open all external links in a new tab.