One of the big issues with markdown is lack of a common standard (CommonMark is fixing that) and hence a variety of incompatible implementations. When there already exists a hugely popular check list extension in the form of GFM, why is there a need to invent another one? I was under the impression that Discourse devs were invested in CommonMark and standardization of markdown.
My issue is not with supporting alternate syntax, I believe in Postel’s law (even though I believe the above issue should have been taken into consideration when the latest syntax changes were done, ie, from [*] to [x]), it is with promoting an incompatible (with GFM) syntax in the plugin doc and not supporting easy migration of the GFM-like task list syntax to the newer format, which broke a lot of my pages on my Discourse instance, see my OP.