Try to passing the created_at variable more specific if you did not.
I just look into the Discourse source code, it using Time.zone.parse to parse your created_at date string, for your example, it result
pry(main)> Time.zone.parse("Oct 14, '11, at 07:45 am").to_s
=> "0011-10-14 07:45:00 UTC"
how about an RFC 3339 string
pry(main)> Time.zone.parse('2011-10-14T14:00:00-10:00').to_s
=> "2011-10-15 00:00:00 UTC"