Thanks for replying.
The plugin could be told only to get the last n items from the feed based on pubDate, so if the link of an old item changes it would be ignored.
This is was I originally thought Maximum number of posts to embed was for (hence some of my initial confusion).
This is what I did in the end.
Putting it all in perspective, I can see that the RSS plugin works all right, and after the initial few items the pubDate and topic creation date will be the same, and usually it won’t be a problem to create a new topic for every item in the feed.