When we select a group of users as the manager of a category (for example, group A), they can act on the topics of that category like a TL4 user. Now suppose the level of trust of the user who is a member of group A is TL3. This means that it can move any topic from the other categories to the desired category first, for example, close it and then return it to the previous category. We have not used this feature yet and I raised this issue based on speculation. Could such a thing happen?

Can anyone confirm or deny this?

Yes, that is exactly how the feature was designed. You should not put a user as a category moderator of you don’t trust him/her, like all staff powers.

Yes, this is true, but there is practically no difference between being a category moderator and being a site moderator for TL3. In other words, if TL3 becomes the category moderator, it has actually become TL4

Did you know you can remove the TL3 topic edit power in the site settings?

No, I forgot that :sweat_smile: I think you mean disabling trusted users can edit others in the site settings. The ability of tl3 users to change titles, categories, and tags is a great help to manage the community. Especially in large forums where more than 1000 topics may be posted daily. But this good feature will disrupt the work of the category manager or in the future the tag manager. I must say that automatically increasing the system trust level in users and increasing their capabilities is different from our trust in the managers we choose. There are various ways to prevent the disruption of these two golden abilities, and I think in the future, Discourse should pay attention to them. For example, I think with the following features, we can provide some facilities to some people with a little more precision. Ability to give more detailed access to groups (such as changing titles) With this feature, you can have better control over the selection of managers. Automatically join users with special badges in groups (such as registering users who have been tl3 for more than a year) With this feature, the system can control group members automatically.

[image] Nildarar: The ability of tl3 users to change titles, categories, and tags is a great help to manage the community. Especially in large forums where more than 1000 topics may be posted daily. But this good feature will disrupt the work of the category manager or in the future the tag manager. Hello :blush: I am forseeing the same issue on my site, as all Users start at Level 3. And we are realising we do not want TL3 users to be recategorizing and undoing the good work of our TL4 Leaders. We noticed that disabling this site setting below, also means that TL4 Users cannot recategorize or edit other Users posts, which is not ideal. [image] Is there a now setting which allows us to control what Trust Level Users must be to recategorise or edit Titles/Tags? @JammyDodger I noticed you have been the fastest in responding to @Nesha’s posts, which we all are very grateful for at Stats :pray: hoping you could help us out again, thanks!

Thanks for your answer. To put it in our context: We got a gated forum for NZ data research community, where all users are verified and approved by Staff, and must login into the forum. After long discussion we concluded that barrier to entry is enough of a protection, and to encourage participation we decided to start with level 3 for all the users. That enables all users to post topics, which on our forum typically are knowledge sharing topics, or questions to the community. In short, users post when they have something useful to share, or have a question someone can answer. From you answer I can deduce that level 3 users should have earned (in our case have been granted ) enough trust to be allowed to re-categorise topics. Personally I can see the logic in that, but we will discuss with our team what potential consequences this can bring… Also, I think allowing this functionality to level3 users goes a bit against the grain of granting bulk topic/posts edit capabilities for level 4 users (Leaders), which your team has introduced few months back.

What does TL3 give these users which TL2 doesn’t though?

Hmm good point thanks, but even if we might have advanced Users too early, there is a potential problem regarding the above where TL3 can override the good work of promoted Category moderators. What are your thoughts on this aspect? Do you have plans to review it?

About the category moderator feature

Product Support

Stephen (Stephen) May 4, 2023, 12:29am 8

This is the problem, TL3 should be attained through effort. You’re breaking trust levels entirely by doing this.

Topic		Replies	Views
What are all the things a category moderator can do? Product Support category-moderators	7	1412	May 21, 2024
Access rights for moving a topic to another category Product Support	7	1278	August 11, 2023
Is auto-promoting TL3s a sensible choice? Community Building trust-levels	20	1280	May 3, 2023
It is possible to remove the ability for level 3 users to recategorize and rename topics? Product Support	1	1729	February 25, 2018
Authority to edit topics for trust level 3 Product Support	1	769	September 6, 2022

About the category moderator feature

Related topics