while I agree with your sentiment @pfaffman I still think its a trade off. There might be a case for having a smaller community that has a more private feel to it. It will definitely affect the way people communicate. For sure less people will participate, but the kind of people that will participate and the way they participate will be different. While the archetype of a forum owner that you describe might seem obnoxious and undesirable the archetype of the user that you keep away this way might also be better kept away under some circumstances. I think it might even lead to a better community if the people that have no stake in it are kept outside.
6 לייקים