That is part of it, but not the silver bullet. The silver bullet is getting your concept right. It’s not enough to assume that just because you find something interesting (or you have a brand) that others will. In order for a community to succeed it has to solve a problem for people.
I do think your approach is the correct one, Jonathan. Narrow scope, direct paths to the key value proposition.
It’s actually not, especially in developer or support communities. In those cases it is important to provide people with the answers they came for as quickly as possible.
@nicopace The first thing you need to establish is what success means for you. Most people say that success is good engagement figures, but that isn’t enough. What objective does engagement meet for your organisation? If I were you, I’d work that out first and then I’d sample a small handful of the community and talk to them directly. Ask them why they use the community and how it could be made more valuable for them. Don’t make any assumptions.
(I also agree with the advice offered by the responders before me, but I think you need to cut to the chase and get some information before making changes.)