Howdy, the plugin mostly works great, thanks. One issue is that I intentionally have WP articles that are old and never posted to Discourse. When any edit is made to those old WP articles, like fixing a typo, a new post is made to Discourse as if that WP article was brand new. That notifies our users about old content they don’t want to see. Is there a way to disable this behaviour? Thanks.

Hey Sam, The plugin gives you various options for deciding when content in Wordpress is posted to Discourse which also cover the publication of old posts. Firstly, check out the “Publishing” settings in WP Discourse which will set the default publication options. Then also check out the WP Discourse sidebar in the post itself when it’s being created or edited. For more background on both, see [תמונה] Install and configure the WP Discourse Wordpress plugin for Discourse Administrators To get started with the WP Discourse Plugin, go through each of these topics in order and watch the videos at the top of the topic. Install the plugin Connect to Discourse Set up Publishing Set up Commenting Set up DiscourseConnect The two main plugin features, Publishing and DiscourseConnect don’t have to be used together. You can just set up Publishing (and Commenting), and not use DiscourseConnect, or just set up DiscourseConnect, or set up both. There’s a short description of each featu…

Hi, chiming in because I’m running into the same behavior as @samtuke and I can’t find a way around it. If an editor corrects something, like a typo, in an old Wordpress article that wasn’t published on Discourse before, it gets published automatically as a new topic. I’d like to prevent this, and only publish newly written posts. I guest I could add a hacky hook to check if post_ID > $lower_treshold_of_post_ID_I_want_to_publish, but perhaps there’s a better solution. Thanks,

Hey @ajolo2ky, could you share the current publish settings you have? Ideally, if you could share the “meta” file from the log viewer.

Sure, These are the Publish settings: [image] This is what I see in the logs, after an editor corrected something in a 2023 (old – I don’t want it to be posted on Discourse) post: [2025-03-12 14:33:09] publish.INFO: create_post.post_success {"wp_title":"title","wp_author_id":"1","wp_post_id":7} [2025-03-12 14:33:09] publish.INFO: create_post.body_valid {"wp_title":"title","wp_author_id":"1","wp_post_id":7} [2025-03-12 14:33:09] publish.INFO: create_post.after_publish {"post_id":7,"remote_post_type":"create_post","discourse_post_id":"2","discourse_topic_id":"9","discourse_permalink":"https://discourse.mydomain.com/t/title/9"} I cannot publicly share the meta contents, but happy to share them privately, if that helps. Thanks!

Thanks for sharing that. The reason existing articles are being published when they’re edited is probably because you have “Auto Publish” enabled, which means the “Publish post to Discourse” checkbox will be auto-checked in the editor. Are you using the “classic” Wordpress editor: [Screenshot 2025-03-13 at 08.50.11] or the new (Gutenberg) editor? [Screenshot 2025-03-13 at 08.50.29]

Yes, that’s the reason, but the behavior I’d expect was to publish new articles, not edited ones. We are using Gutenberg. I know I can disable the default behavior, and then manually selecting new posts to be published on Discourse, but I was hoping for a better resolution :slight_smile:

All I know the logic where new articles will be published to Discourse already published to Discourse should be updated when edited old articles should not publish to Discourse when edited sounds a bit confusing. Without no better understanding about coding than one hello worls test using Virtual Basic, I could guess it can be done comparing status of article against Discourse status, but such actions has tendency to slowing down admin side. Or that would be the situation at some time in pass :man_shrugging: Thinking about settings that would be very confusing setup.

@ajolo2ky I understand why you might expect it to work that way, indeed this is something that has niggled at me for some time. The reason it hasn’t worked that way in the past is due to the complexities of supporting auto-publish across both Gutenberg and Classic editors. Many folks still use the Classic editor. I looked at a possible improvement to the Gutenberg behaviour this morning and am hoping to get an update in the next version. In the meantime just uncheck “Publish to Discourse” or disable Auto Publish if you don’t want posts to be published in that scenario. I’ll update you here if/when the next version is released with the updated behaviour. Hopefully in about a week from now.

Hi Angus, thank you very much. Following up to see if you had any updates on this. Thanks!

Hey @ajolo2ky, thanks for your patience. I’ve been waiting on a few other (unrelated) pieces for the next version of the Wordpress plugin. I’ll let you know when the next version of the plugin is released and ask you to test the new behaviour in this respect. Thanks!

ביטול פרסום מאמרי WordPress ל-Discourse כאשר הם מתעדכנים

תמיכה WordPress

ajolo2ky (Ariel Jolo) 27 במרץ,‏ 2025,‏ 2:44am 10

שלום אנסגוס, תודה רבה. אני מברר אם יש עדכונים בנושא הזה.

תודה!

נושא		תגובות	צפיות
Possible to post already published posts from WordPress to Discourse? WordPress	3	1834	28 ביוני,‏ 2022
Deactivate auto publish discourse to post wordpress WordPress	7	3608	29 בינואר,‏ 2021
Editing linked Discourse posts/topics without changes being overridden by Wordpress? WordPress	14	2071	16 באוקטובר,‏ 2017
Plugin tries to re-publish to Discourse after every update WordPress	15	591	28 במאי,‏ 2024
A specific Discourse topic isn't updated when the WP article is updated WordPress	2	692	12 ביולי,‏ 2021

ביטול פרסום מאמרי WordPress ל-Discourse כאשר הם מתעדכנים

נושאים קשורים