Hey :wave: Today I saw a disgusting opportunity, the administrator can read private messages of users without leaving the admin panel. Also administrator can hide login in user account, bypassing the password and 2FA to read encrypted messages (Discourse Encrypt). I suspect that I am not the only one in horror of the administrator’s rights and the position of Developers Discourse is unchanged - the privacy of users does not cost anything. I want to ask, maybe someone found a solution to this problem to make the administrator’s capabilities more transparent and notify the user that an administrator authorized in his account or read it PM?

[image] RedBear: Yes, I used this plugin and can read encrypt messages via admin panel. It’s very sad. Actually, no. You cannot read encrypted messages of other users unless you have their key to decrypt it. Encryption/decryption happens on the client side, not on the server, and encrypted messages are stored encrypted on the server. The ability of admins to read personal messages is an oft discussed issue and won’t be changed. If you are concerned about privacy and security, then strictly limit who has admin access and only log in as admin yourself when you need to change site settings or download a backup. You seem to be pretty uphappy with Discourse. It is open source so you are welcome to use different software.

There is a setting in the backend that will log anytime an admin opens another user’s message: [image] It won’t notify the end user, but it does at least leave an entry. Is that sufficient for your purposes?

No, this action in logs can view only admin/moderator. I want notify users if admin/moderator sign in user accounts or if read private user messages. Notify to PM via system bot or show this log actions in users profile, for example create menu “logs” in users account setting, where users can view this action (sign in/read PM from admin/moders).

If I recall, the PM accessibility feature is only available to admins. Mods cannot open other users’ messages. So the simple answer is you only give admin access to those who specifically service and manage the Discourse instance itself. From a technical standpoint, those managing your instance could get access to the PMs from the database itself without generating log entries. As an admin of the site and the server it’s on, the only way to ultimately prevent admins from gaining that level of access is to encrypt the contents with a key they don’t have. For the level of security you’re looking for, you basically need this: [image] Discourse Encrypt (deprecated) Plugin play_button Original Plugin Description Last edited by @david 2024-12-03T15:46:08Z (UTC) play_button Check document I haven’t used it (yet), but I believe it generates and stores the keys client-side in a way where they wouldn’t be accessible via the impersonation feature. The key is still stored locally and impersonating shouldn’t provide access to it (as far as I’m aware). This is really the only way to protect the data in the database itself.

I’m very annoying that the Discourse “open source” strongly limits my opportunities administrator, he is very limited in the subtle settings of this forum, I can’t: disable e-mail activation delete default bagdes change nginx CSP for secure onebox (iplogger) clear all logs, statistics install plugins via admin panel install without docker with domain (not localhost) view who online without plugin (lmao) install Discourse on non-USA server locale set username/password to my database when forum install But Discourse is very good product to spying for users and logs more information about users activity. Discourse Encrypt (deprecated) Yes, I used this plugin and can read encrypt messages via admin panel. It’s very sad.

[image] tobiaseigen: You cannot read encrypted messages Man, I’m test it today. [image] tobiaseigen: You seem to be pretty uphappy with Discourse. It is open source so you are welcome to use different software. Yes, security and privacy are very important in any software. Therefore, I will accept your offer and refuse to use spying Discourse.

[image] RedBear: Man, I’m test it today. Are you sure you were looking at encrypted messages? The user has to actually set it up and start using it to send/receive messages. Existing messages created before they do this won’t be encrypted, and they can also still choose to send unencrypted messages. [image] RedBear: Therefore, I will accept your offer and refuse to use spying Discourse. Sorry to hear it but wish you all the best, and good luck!

[image] tobiaseigen: Are you sure you were looking at encrypted messages? The user has to actually set it up and start using it to send/receive messages. Existing messages created before they do this won’t be encrypted, and they can also still choose to send unencrypted messages Yup. I enabled this plugin on fresh install by default for all users. [image] tobiaseigen: Sorry to hear it but wish you all the best, and good luck! Ciao!

[image] RedBear: Man, I’m test it today. I think you are looking at unencrypted messages. The admin would have to know the users password in order to decrypt the messages and password are stored hashed PBKDF2 which makes it costly and lengthy process to bruteforce the hashes. The encrypted PM plugin has an expiry function if you need extra privacy. In any case, even if the admin UI wouldn’t have the PM reading option they would still be in the database in cleartext unless using encryption plugin. Open-source doesn’t mean privacy I guess you’re confusing terms.

How alert if admin/mods read users PM?

Product Support

RedBear (Red Bear) February 14, 2022, 3:47pm 7

Man, I’m test it today.

Yes, security and privacy are very important in any software.

Therefore, I will accept your offer and refuse to use spying Discourse.

Topic		Replies	Views
PMs are accesible by admins if the admin has the link Feature	12	1856	December 2, 2021
Are PMs truly private and not crawlable? Community Building	4	1401	August 16, 2020
How to make it so that admins are not able to view private messages of their users? Product Support	10	2097	May 9, 2019
Ethics: admin should access private messages in strict read-only mode Feature	13	4338	September 17, 2015
Privacy plugin that makes it more difficult for admins to read PMs Feature personal-messages	55	7723	February 6, 2018

How alert if admin/mods read users PM?

Related topics