Notification level 1 is ‘Normal’, so that would be expected. And you only get a record in the topic_users table if you’ve visited the topic, so that is expected too. ![]()
It sounds like you may have flipped on some topic notification levels when you tweaked some settings. Could you have a look specifically for anyone who is Watching a topic in a muted category, and see if they’re the people affected in your original issue?
Actually, if they’re marked as Normal in the topic I think that would override the category mute too. You may have landed on the answer.
I think your previous settings change could have mass-set everyone’s topic notification level, and changing it again only affected new topics going forward.
