Whenever I have seen that error I have seen a ruby backtrace in the logs. I recommend that you tail that file and reload the page. It can be hard to catch as lots of stuff happens. You can also search that file for 500, though often there will be some 500 strings that are not the error so you have to keep looking. You can also look in error.log.
You can certainly try removing that and any other plugins and rebuilding, especially if you have any non standard plugins.