We’re thinking of changing our setting for max image size kb, as we we started out with it quite high and need to save some S3 costs. I wanted to check my understanding before hitting the button. I think this setting on setting only gets applied to new uploads? Is there a way to resize existing uploads to use the new max value (e.g. resize the originals of anything over the max)? I’m was sort of hoping something like bundle exec rake posts:rebake would do it (maybe)? If that wouldn’t work, what’s the best approach here? An older build of discourse had a Rails script/downsize_uploads.rb but I think that’s gone from github now? Is there anything else or is my best bet just to use that code on a more recent Discourse - I think it uses megapixel as the constraint rather than kb? Thanks for any help/advice.

[image] fearlessfrog: An older build of discourse had a Rails script/downsize_uploads.rb but I think that’s gone from github now? It was converted into rake uploads:downsize. Be sure to glance over the script code as this is a destructive action. [image] fearlessfrog: We’re thinking of changing our setting for max image size kb Nowadays the client side image compression should yield enough saving to keep image uploads in check. Do you have it enabled?

We have client compression working and it does really well at keeping the image sizes down since it was introduced. We’ve been live with Discourse since about May 2015, and probably never changed the max image size before so that rask task looks ideal - thank you!

[image] Falco: Be sure to glance over the script code as this is a destructive action. Apologies in that I can’t sign the CLA due to my work, so without a PR wanted to pass on that.. lib/tasks/uploads.rake 1d42cc94a # For example, if you want 4 concurrent scripts use WORKER_COUNT=4 # and WORKER_ID from 0 to 3. # # START_ID # Skip uploads with id lower than START_ID. task "uploads:downsize" => :environment do min_image_pixels = 500_000 # 0.5 megapixels default_image_pixels = 1_000_000 # 1 megapixel max_image_pixels = [ ARGV[0]&.to_i || default_image_pixels, min_image_pixels ].max ENV["VERBOSE"] = "1" if ENV["INTERACTIVE"] def log(*args) puts(*args) if ENV["VERBOSE"] end puts "", "Downsizing images to no more than #{max_image_pixels} pixels" ..needs to be ARGV[1], otherwise it’s always using 500_000 regardless of what’s passed in. Thanks again for the pointer to the right task, all files resized and working great. :heart:

[image] fearlessfrog: discourse/lib/tasks/uploads.rake at 1d42cc94a2c74633178d4e75560368d89576f2aa · discourse/discourse · GitHub …needs to be ARGV[1], otherwise it’s always using 500_000 regardless of what’s passed in. cc @cvx, do we need to update that?

Changing max_image_size_kb

Product Support

Falco (Falco) December 5, 2022, 9:48pm 5

cc @cvx, do we need to update that?

Topic		Replies	Views
Resizing images after upload settings Self-hosting	25	5328	April 17, 2022
Downsize and Convert Image Uploads Product Support	1	618	March 17, 2022
Resizing images after user has uploaded automatically Product Support	17	1018	April 20, 2020
Image upload size/resize question Product Support	24	6336	April 4, 2021
Images are still too big -- how to compress further? Product Support	20	8564	February 22, 2020

Changing max_image_size_kb

Related topics