Users without reply permission are wrongly given option to reply by email in notification

I have only one category with security settings like that.

Can you share a screen shot of those settings with us please @Horus ?

Sure. It’s German, but I think you’ll get the idea:

(problems uploading the screenshot from my current location, will add it today’s evening).

The settings are

  • Vorstand (group): View, Reply, Create
  • Everybody: View, --, –

The user who gets the mail with the option to reply is not in the Vorstand group.

EDIT: Screenshot

Best Thanks!