Understandable. However, it depends on the use case. For forums/communities, what you said makes perfect sense. But I want to use Discourse as a blog, and this feature request would be valuable, I don’t want to have blog visitors promote themselves to more rights all of a sudden.
So, a vote from me as well for this feature. Until then, I will do the same workaround but it would be nice to have it.
(Sorry for ressing an old topic, I needed to ask the same question so I found this).