The bookmarks UI changed recently in a mostly good way. And… it seems that the behavior silently(!!!) changed as well. Previously, if I set a reminder on a bookmark, the bookmark was cleaned out after the notification (per an Easter egg setting). Now… that doesn’t seem to be the case? I noticed the other day that reminder bookmarks I’ve set since the UI change are still in my bookmark list, even though I’ve already gotten the notifications. Y’all keep moving my features out from under me. :frowning:

In the menu where you can choose a custom time for the reminder, you can also configure what happens after you are notified. [_20240607_165100] Like the option to add notes to the bookmark, this is now more difficult to discover because the dropdown only refers to reminders.

[image] Moin: In the menu where you can choose a custom time :woman_facepalming: This was already set for me: [Selection_1835] So apparently it’s only honored if I ignore the super-tempting quick-choice dropdown from the button and go to Custom. So we’ve added a step (choose ‘Custom’ in the dropdown) to get the same functionality. :unamused: :woman_facepalming: :unamused: :woman_facepalming: :unamused: :woman_facepalming: :unamused: :woman_facepalming: :unamused:

You can also set your default behavior in your User → Interface settings [This image shows various settings and options related to browser notifications, including enabling quote reply for highlighted text, automatically unpinning topics when reaching the bottom, showing counts on the browser icon, and options for handling bookmark reminder notifications. (Captioned by AI)]

Thanks for the followup @keegan 2 things First, I guess we can mark this one completed: [image] Bookmarks vs reminders Feature IIRC, there used to be reminders. Then they got rolled into bookmarks as a feature. Took me a while (and a post here IIRC) to re-find them. Okay, fine. I guess I set a bookmark now. So I started using bookmarks, which appear to default to ‘reminder’ functionality: [Selection_445] 95% of the UI is about timing, so this must just be a renaming of reminders, right? Ehm, no. I now occasionally re-stumble over the fact that the bookmark is retained after I’m notified of it. Really not the behavi… Second, it was already set that way when I got to the page: [Selection_1837]

Bookmark behavior changed along with UI?

Product Support

ganncamp (G Ann Campbell) June 10, 2024, 12:13pm 6

I set some tests Friday. Bookmark alerts seem a bit resistant to being marked ‘read’, but once they finally give in, they do disappear from the list as they should.

Topic		Replies	Views
Bookmarks vs reminders Feature bookmarks	2	857	September 15, 2022
I disagree with the location of the bookmark reminder notification preference UX bookmarks	0	101	August 22, 2025
Ability to set 'Remind me' topic timer has disappeared...? Product Support topic-timers	4	1328	October 5, 2020
Wishlist: 'Note to self' in bookmark/reminder Feature bookmarks	9	574	June 20, 2024
Wrong icon when you use a custom reminder for your bookmark UX completed , bookmarks	1	379	April 9, 2024

Bookmark behavior changed along with UI?

Related topics