Hi, When Discourse sends email, it uses the server name in the SMTP From transaction. The problem with that, is that I relay it to an upstream server to do the actual sending, and if it fails to send, the bounce message never gets back to the server (this is fine; I don’t want Discourse to receive email). But the bounces pile up in our postmaster inbox. Is it possible to set the SMTP From to some other hostname, so that the bounces go to a valid email address and can be handled appropriately (eg by telling the user to fix their dang email address)? I have already tried setting the Notification Email setting in the admin panel, but the upstream server ignores that and tries to send the bounce to the upstream server it actually received the email from instead of to the From path in the actual email.

[image] rbos: I have already tried setting the Notification Email setting in the admin panel The notification email setting is used in the From mail header (RFC822), but (as you note) for this purpose you want to set the Envelope From that’s used in the SMTP transaction (RFC5321). Discourse uses reply_by_email_address here. The most integrated solution is to set the reply_by_email_address to something that gets delivered back to Discourse so that it automatically handles bounces. That’s what we do on our hosting platform. I’d suggest reading through this: Configure direct-delivery incoming email for self-hosted sites with Mail-Receiver

Changing email SMTP From

Product Support

tobiaseigen (Tobias Eigen) September 22, 2025, 11:57pm 2

Were you able to resolve your issue? Seems you are trying to do some complicated things with Discourse.

Topic		Replies	Views
From / Reply / bounce email issue Product Support	9	2568	May 23, 2016
Bounced emails not being detected Product Support email	16	1871	February 7, 2024
How do I change the email "FROM" address? Product Support	8	1038	September 5, 2020
Turning off email for a user Product Support email	7	391	September 2, 2024
Email notifications reply directly to me (the admin) Product Support	3	1768	June 23, 2021

Changing email SMTP From

Related topics