Not sure if this is intended behaviour, but I just discovered that my emailed reply to a forum PM message notification sent to me, was automatically posted to the forum complete with my email signature, along with the full email thread leading to my reply (duplicating content already visible in the PM thread online). Is there any reason why emailed replies to PM notifications should behave differently to emailed replies to forum topic notifications? Emailed replies to topic notifications normally have my signature, and any email thread that follows it automatically stripped out. Could this be some sort of regression associated with a recent update?

Interesting! So maybe this can be isolated to outlook for android. I looked at the message source for your post and don’t see the -- signature separator. Maybe you want to add that to your signature on outlook on your phone? :thinking: Might be interesting for you to try to reply to the same post by email using outlook on your windows machine and again using outlook on your phone, to see if it successfully strips out the signature.

[图片] Paul_King: Could this be some sort of regression associated with a recent update? perhaps, i’d recommend disabling and re-enabling [IMG_1677]

Thanks @Ethsim2 - just tried that, but no change

maybe doing the same with this setting would help? [IMG_1680]

Is this a change you are reporting? A new behavior to something you’ve done before? Or are you doing something you’ve not done before and expecting a different behavior than you are seeing? This sometimes happens depending on the email client you are using. Outlook is notoriously hard to work with. We will often edit replies we receive by email to fix formatting or to remove extraneous text. The only want to be certain is to edit your email before sending to remove the content you don’t want to have posted.

I think this is new behaviour, as I have not seen it before with other PMs posted from the same outlook email application. I also regularly reply by email to the main forum topics on my own forum, and here from Outlook - with none of my signatures or previous thread (consisting of the original notification) coming through

This stuff is hard to troubleshoot, I’m afraid. Could you test it using gmail or some other email client, and see if you are able to replicate the problem?

I think this may be new behaviour, as I have not seen it before with other PMs posted from outlook. I also regularly reply by email to the main forum topics on my own forum, and to here, from Outlook - with none of my signatures or previous thread (consisting of the original notification) coming through. In fairness this is usually from Outlook in Windows, and it occurs to me the issue was exposed using the Outlook app on my Android Mobile phone. Using this reply from my mobile as a test. Paul King Freelance Architect B.BSc, B.Arch (1st Class Hons), ANZIA 027 2352268 | www.prime.net.nz sent from my smartphone EDIT : … and now I can see the phone version of my signature is not being stripped out, although the notification email I replied to is being stripped out.

Testing with mobile signature amended to include signature separator… Edit: … which does seem to have worked!

Hopefully if everything following the separator is removed, then my PM replies will also have the trailing thread stripped off too, as they are to the main forum

Yes, that is the idea with the signature separator - everything below it is stripped. Can you check one thing for me? When you set up a new signature for outlook for android, does it insert the -- separator by default, and you removed it? Or did they neglect to insert it by default? If so then that may be a bug report to send to Microsoft.

PM回复邮件似乎回避了删除其电子邮件签名和完整消息历史记录

产品支持

tobiaseigen (Tobias Eigen) 2025 年8 月 27 日 10:00 7

恐怕这东西很难排查。您能否使用 Gmail 或其他电子邮件客户端进行测试，看看是否能重现问题？

话题		回复	浏览量
Reply by e-mail message clip bug Product Support email	8	282	2025 年8 月 29 日
Email reply parsing Bug email	9	3451	2016 年3 月 29 日
Only reply to PMs by email Feature	3	920	2025 年5 月 12 日
[ is stripped from reply by email Product Support	4	687	2018 年5 月 17 日
Email signature not being stripped out when user write new topic or reply to a topic Product Support	39	4493	2022 年5 月 9 日

PM回复邮件似乎回避了删除其电子邮件签名和完整消息历史记录

相关话题