I am happy that large image uploads are now being resized, but its not taking a 4.6MB image down to 1MB - I recently set the max image size to 1024K and tried uploading a 4.6MB image and got a too-large error. Looking at the code it is doing a 80%-resize up to 2 times and if its not small enough by…

Because there’s no way to 1) predict how long a downsize operation will take and 2) know what % we need to use to downsize a xMB image to 1MB image. If you know the answer to either one of those points, please share :raised_hands: So we do it the hard way. We indeed only do 2 80-%-downsizes. From …

Yes, in thinking about it its harder than I was expecting. Here is a Stack Overflow post with some good ideas: [Pablo Fernandez] How to resize an image in C# to a certain hard-disk size? c#, image, image-processing, image-manipulation asked by Pablo Fernan…

I’d happily merge a PR replacing the hardcoded-80-% with a decent heuristic :wink:

Following up on my old post here.. I noticed after a recent update we were not getting any resizing to work. In looking at the code, there are a couple of recent commits to uploads_controller.rb that look like it broke the resizing. One is loop exit condition break if downsized_size >= uploaded_s…

Sure @zogstrip can have a look.

Thanks for all your suggestions! They’re now implemented :wink: https://github.com/discourse/discourse/commit/7fca6f502ffaaccbeda7453ec743625690fdb051

Update: I patched my production site with the revised code and all is working good for a day now :smile: I set the max size to 2mb and many images are getting resized. Now that I worked on this I belatedly noticed you un-deprecated the Amazon S3 image storage option. So, its much less of a life-o…

Large image resize - why only 64% scaling at most?

Support

scottfsmith (Scott Smith) 20 يونيو 2016، 12:29م 8

Cool! Code looks great now. I will give it some tests on my dev server at some point. The ratios I picked in the table were based on eyeball calculations so they may not be perfect. But they should not be too far off.

الموضوع		الردود	مرات العرض
Resizing images after upload settings Self-hosting	25	5179	17 أبريل 2022
Unable to resize images after uploading Bug	4	2114	17 أغسطس 2015
Image upload max size and further resizing regression issue Feature	16	4584	3 مايو 2018
Image upload error when using resizer Bug	7	2231	25 مارس 2020
Image upload size/resize question Support	24	6219	4 أبريل 2021

Large image resize - why only 64% scaling at most?

الموضوعات ذات الصلة