I’m curious what actually makes a new member feel welcome when a community is already busy and full of long-running threads. Is it a friendly first reply, a clear place to introduce yourself, or something else entirely? I’d love to hear what worked for you when you first joined a community like this one.
AI-generated summary
The discussion explores effective strategies for welcoming new members in busy online communities. jainmike initiates the conversation by asking what makes newcomers feel welcomed amidst long-running threads, questioning whether friendly replies, clear introduction spaces, or other methods work best.
satonotdead offers technical solutions for self-hosted instances or dedicated plans, suggesting the use of Workflows to automate welcome messages via private chats or dedicated topics. They also mention gating access through categories and custom groups, unlocked via badges, to facilitate structured welcomes by staff. Additionally, they note that Discourse’s built-in discobot, while outdated, can handle simple, neutral welcomes with configurable text.
Rubi emphasizes the importance of a personal touch, advocating for warm greetings, smiles, and providing useful links to help new users navigate. They recommend having an “Introductions” category for users to share details about themselves.
Ed_S agrees that a dedicated “Introduce Yourself” topic or category is beneficial, though they prefer a single topic to keep things organized. They also suggest explicitly welcoming users upon their first contribution to a thread. Ed_S links to a related discussion on keeping long-running discussions easy to follow.
thequranclass, sharing a fresh perspective as a new member, highlights that a quick sign-up process and reading existing topics helped them understand community norms. They appreciated earning the “Basic” badge as a small milestone. They concur with Rubi and Ed_S that a personal, friendly first reply is crucial when navigating an unfamiliar environment.
If you host your own instance or are on a dedicated plan, you can do this in several ways:
- Automating via Workflows a welcome message in a direct or group chat, or a private message.
- Automating a message in a topic where you send welcomes, also using Workflows.
- Filtering categories with specific custom groups and permissions for “unlocking” access as the user progresses and introduces themselves through badges and some queries, to then be welcomed by staff or existing users.
Discourse includes discobot in its core; although it is outdated, it can work well for simple, neutral welcomes. The text of the messages sent is translatable, and you can configure them from your admin panel.
I think the personal touch is always best.
Saying hello, giving a smile, being open and warm to new users, perhaps providing them with a link or links to useful information specific to the site is also a nice way to bring people closer.
Having an Introductions category where they can say hi and perhaps write something about themselves if they want…seems to work.
See also the nearby How do you keep long-running discussions easy to follow?
For me, an Introduce Yourself topic has worked well. Possibly a category, but I prefer a topic. Any discursive followup may well be re-threaded into a new topic by a moderator.
In some circumstances, I might post an explicit welcome when a person first contributes to a thread, and I might suggest an introductory post in the appropriate place.
As someone who joined just yesterday, a couple of things stood out for me. Signing up was quick — a code by email and I was in — and simply reading a few topics helped me get a feel for how the community talks and what is expected. Earning the Basic badge after reading felt like a small milestone, which was encouraging. I agree with Rubi and Ed_S that a personal hello matters most; a friendly first reply goes a long way when everything else is still unfamiliar.