Request: new polling method "Systemic Konsensiering" (DE:Systemisches Konsensieren)

It would be really great to have some kind of consensus-building plugin for discourse because it might contribute to a better understanding of what consensus is and how practical it actually is (contrary to it’s reputation). In fact, we all use the consensus principle all the time, but more on that below.

There are lots of ways of practicing consensus decision-making and the ones mentioned in this topic are just some of them. And that is the first (and perhaps biggest) challenge of creating a popular plugin rather than having dozens of them, each limited to a particular flavour of consensus. The plugin would have to be flexible enough to accommodate many/most of these flavours…

I don’t have a silver bullet, but here is one important insight that might help understand what all the different versions of consensus have in common: consensus is not unanimity. Indeed, although the two look very similar on the surface, they differ fundamentally. In short: consensus is about nobody disagreeing, unanimity is about everyone agreeing.

In order to find out whether everyone agrees, everyone needs to express their preference, i.e. to cast a vote of some sort. A unanimous decision is achieved through voting.

Consensus, by contrast does not require everyone to express a preference. It only requires that no one objects. This makes consensus so incredibly powerful and flexible but it (at least in its basic form) also allows decisions that no one really likes but also doesn’t dislike enough to object (also known as the “Abilene Paradox”).

For a more detailed discussion of consensus and unanimity see this blog post:

Just to be clear: this post is not meant as a critique of any of the previous posts in this topic. I am not proposing any specific implementation of a consensus method, I’m just suggesting a way of thinking about and understanding consensus.

4 Likes