I expect that this is not a simple change and it is worth considering some potential issues using it and developing it.
The proposed feature, a site setting, default off, for “allow badges on restricted categories”, is not inherently community-building for the entire community or forum.
So the current default makes sense for Discourse:
- Intending to build a community.
- Having all the gaming elements … in service of a higher purpose (https://blog.codinghorror.com/)
Some badges naturally force users to involve themselves outside their group simply because of the hundreds of users that need to be involved:
Good sharebadgeGreat sharebadge
Awarding some badges can be weird for a team who all interact in a restricted category, more so if the team also see each other face-to-face:
First flagof a post - admittedly an unlikely situation?New user of the month
The value of a topic/post badge earned among tens of users is probably less than for the entire community of hundreds or thousands.
I do have a private community which has a restricted category for each team’s group. We could use the proposed feature but we probably won’t because we want to encourage interaction and sharing between the teams.