Oh, that’s insane. So instead I have to play a game? Hmm, how do I get past the idiot computer sentry that’s preventing me from accepting my perfectly reasonable posting?
Different case. You’re talking about completely wide-open email in the case of Google, vs. a closed set of trusted users in the case of Discourse. (As in my other post, if a Discourse instance deals with large numbers of users, then perhaps it makes sense not to explain reasoning to those at lowest trust levels, but for trusted users they should be able to know why their post was not accepted, so they can quickly fix their work, rather than have their flow of thought disrupted.)