Which setting for anyone following along? I don’t think I had to change anything, so just curious.
I think this is by design and the same happens if you send an email to a Discourse group. It is designed to work just like email as in the user might not even know they are sending an email into a Discourse forum. If I send you a regular email to your email account I don’t get a reply back from your email provider that says you received my email, we just trust that it works.
Here is an example email notification a staged user will receive:
but this is what a non-staged user will receive:
There appears to be a difference between staged users and non-staged users. Likely because the user is staged it is to be just like interacting via regular email.