I liked your post before you edited it because you posted:
which is a workable approach.
However, your edit suggests that what you are wanting is either a type of confirm message box every time you create a topic, or the code to be able to somehow know your intentions and interrupt the process when it detects that you are about to make a mistake.
The first would get old fast, the second is not possible.
I think the best you could do is have a plugin that sets a personal default category for you when you don’t explicitly assign a category.