Valid concern, but if everything is setup correctly by specifying which URL is the canonical one google won’t have any issues.
You absolutely can just use Discourse, but here would be a few benefits to using a blog (whether it be WordPress, the built in Shopify one, or some other platform):
- Longer topic previews (or show the whole post) when you go to the blog page rather than just looking at titles that you have to click on.
- It’s part of your sales pipeline. Due to the design of the blog vs the forum it might be easier for someone to stumble upon a blog post and then easily end up on the “buy” page or sign up for an email newsletter.
- It can be a lot easier for users to scroll through and read just the blog posts compared to being distracted by all the user generated content on the forum.
- Having a blog also I think paints the clear distinction between only we can create blog posts compared to user generated content on the forum.
- A separate (possibly) cleaner design with one purpose
- Ordering. Blog posts are always in the same order, but topics on a forum will get bumped if a user comments on them.
Does everyone need a blog? Nope. I think you just need to analyze what your business/community needs are.
But I am very interested in people just using Discourse as a blogging platform. Even though Discourse is a forum at heart, I think with some plugins like https://meta.discourse.org/t/topic-list-previews/41630 and maybe a few other changes you can make a pretty nice looking blog.