I don’t think it’s completely unreasonable. Google’s job as a search engine is getting you the most relevant information as fast as possible — if a static HTML page has content of identical relevance they should probably favor that over downloading a web app… it’s totally likely you might not ever have a subsequent visit anyway (and if you do, I imagine that’s a bigger relevance factor than speed anyway).
Important to note that Google also reaffirms in their post that they’re only going to be penalizing the slowest of the slow… and more relevant content will likely always win anyway.