Some numbers for context:
On desktop (first view empty cache)
- https://stackoverflow.com — 2.3 seconds 445K ( result )
- https://meta.discourse.org — 4.2 seconds 869K ( result )
- https://www.nytimes.com — 9.4 seconds 3600K ( result )
On mobile moto G (first view empty cache)
- https://stackoverflow.com — 2.6 seconds 220K ( result )
- https://meta.discourse.org — 8.8 seconds 827K ( result )
- https://www.nytimes.com — 46 seconds (interactive in 6) 6400K ( result )
Given that Discourse is an entirely JavaScript based application I think it stacks up quite well even against traditional “non JS” sites.
Despite the slightly slower initial load on mobile, using Discourse on mobile is FAR more enjoyable than other sites cause it has only a tiny network footprint while browsing around.
There is no chance Discourse is going to be punished here due to any of the numbers I am seeing, though as always we strive to make Discourse faster and better every release despite needing to ship an entire “engine” to a client to run the forum.