Is the StackOverflow Enterprise/Teams software a better Q&A solution than Discourse with the Q&A plugin?

While the distinction between a discussion site and a Q&A site is a useful ideal type, real world needs are often less either/or. In particular, when answers are developed gradually and involving both the experts and those who ask questions, the process will soon resemble a discussion, not necessarily between conflicting opinions but between clarifying answers and clarifying questions.

It’s not by chance that the stack sites originated in a technical context where the need for such a ping pong process is usually limited. And with the very limited comments functionality, the limited need for discussion is accommodated reasonably well. But, for example, there is no way to acknowledge the contribution made by an answer except for upvoting it, which, I believe, formally endorses the answer as the correct answer and that is not quite the same as saying “thanks for your useful contribution”.

Here is an example of a patent related question where I experienced precisely these limitations:

tl;dr While I wouldn’t want to miss the Q&A sites, I think that for the vast majority of intranet sites, discourse will be the better option because it is much more flexible in allowing different types of interactions, including Q&A.

7 Likes